Talk about hit or miss. When Hilton was good he was great, but when he was bad, he was downright depressing. If five catches and 50 yards is your benchmark for consistency (which is a bit modest), Hilton failed to reach that benchmark in nine of his 16 contests. Three times he put up two catch clunkers which is not going to get the job done. Five times he eclipsed 120 yards receiving. His five touchdowns came in two games (2 vs. Seattle and 3 vs. Houston) which is a little more famine than feast.